IFRS 18 Presentation and Disclosure of Financial Statements
is not only changing the structure of the Statement of Profit or Loss
and introducing Management-Defined Performance Measures.
It also strengthens how accountants should think about
aggregation and disaggregation.
The Objective Is Simple
Financial statements should provide a useful summary without allowing
material information to disappear inside broad balances.
This does not mean showing every transaction separately.
It means finding the right balance between grouping information that
shares similar characteristics and separating information when
aggregation would obscure something material.
Similar Characteristics
Group information that shares similar characteristics.
Material Information
Separate information where aggregation would obscure
something material.
Useful Summary
Avoid turning the financial statements into a transaction-by-transaction listing.
The underlying concepts are not entirely new.
IAS 1 already required material information to be presented separately
and items with similar characteristics to be aggregated.
IFRS 18 develops these principles into a more structured approach.
| IAS 1 — BEFORE | IFRS 18 — NOW |
|---|---|
| Aggregate items with similar characteristics. | Identify the characteristics of items before deciding whether they should be aggregated. |
| Present material items separately. | Assess whether aggregation could obscure material information. |
| Significant preparer judgment over the level of detail. | More structured judgment over what to aggregate, what to disaggregate and where to disclose it. |
| Broad captions could contain several components. | Broad captions should be assessed to determine whether material or dissimilar components require further information. |
The Accountant’s Question Is Changing
“What sits inside this line, and are we hiding information
that users need to understand?”
Assume the trial balance contains:
Administrative Expenses: $15,000,000.
| IAS 1 — Typical Presentation | US $ | IFRS 18 — More Informative Analysis | US $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Administrative Expenses | 15,000,000 | Administrative Expenses | 15,000,000 |
| Employee costs | 8,000,000 | ||
| Professional fees | 3,500,000 | ||
| IT expenses | 2,500,000 | ||
| Legal settlement | 1,000,000 | ||
| The total may be presented with limited breakdown. | Management assesses whether combining the components would obscure material information and whether further disaggregation is required. |
||
The important point is not that IFRS 18 automatically requires all
the mentioned components to appear separately on the P&L.
The accountant must determine whether additional information is
necessary and where that information should appear.
That could mean separate presentation in the primary financial statement
or additional disaggregation in the notes.
Consider another common account:
Other Income — $2,500,000.
| IAS 1 — Broad Caption | US $ | IFRS 18 — Analyze the Components as Ledger Analysis Shows | US $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Other Income | 2,500,000 | Gain on disposal | 1,000,000 |
| Government grants | 800,000 | ||
| Dividend income | 500,000 | ||
| FX gain | 200,000 | ||
| Total Other Income | 2,500,000 | Total Other Income | 2,500,000 |
| Different sources may sit within one broad account. | Determine whether aggregation remains appropriate or whether material information needs to be separately presented or disclosed. |
||
This is where IFRS 18 can have a practical impact on the chart
of accounts and reporting structure.
If the accounting system only records
Other Income → $2,500,000,
the accountant may have difficulty producing the required analysis.
The books need to preserve enough information to identify
what generated the balance.
This is equally important.
Too much disaggregation can make financial statements less useful,
not more useful.
Imagine presenting telephone, mobile, internet, printer,
stationery, courier, office refreshments and small repairs
as separate P&L lines when none is individually material.
That would create clutter rather than insight.
Aggregate
Similar information should be grouped to provide a clear summary.
Disaggregate
Separate information enough to ensure material information
is not obscured.
Avoid
Too much insignificant detail that creates clutter rather than insight.
Before grouping transactions together, consider their characteristics.
Nature
What is the expense or income:
salary, impairment, professional fee, grant,
litigation settlement, depreciation, etc.
Function
What activity does it support:
production, administration, selling, distribution, etc.
Other Characteristics
Do the items arise differently, have different measurement bases
or possess other characteristics that make separating them useful?
Materiality
Would hiding the component inside a larger balance reasonably
affect a user’s understanding of the financial statements?
These considerations help determine whether information
should be aggregated or disaggregated.
The change should not start when the financial statements are drafted.
Consider this existing structure:
| BEFORE | IFRS 18-READY |
|---|---|
Other Income: Everything is posted into one account. |
Other Income: Government grants; Dividend income; Disposal gains; Foreign exchange gains. |
This does not necessarily mean creating four new GL accounts.
The entity could instead use
sub-accounts, transaction codes, reporting dimensions,
ERP tags, or reliable supporting schedules.
What matters is that the accountant can move from:
Disaggregation does not automatically mean adding another line
to the face of the P&L.
The primary financial statements should provide a useful structured summary.
The notes then provide the additional material information necessary
to understand that summary.
The accountant therefore has two decisions to make:
Before IFRS 18 becomes effective:
IFRS 18 does not require accountants to turn the financial statements
into a detailed general ledger.
Nor does it allow material information to disappear behind broad captions
such as “Other Income” or
“Administrative Expenses.”
Similar Information
Aggregate
Material Information That Could Be Obscured
Disaggregate
Too Much Insignificant Detail
Avoid
The ultimate question is:
“Does presenting these amounts together provide a useful summary —
or does it hide information users need to understand?”
This is the aggregation and disaggregation discipline
IFRS 18 brings into financial reporting.
| Abbreviation | Meaning |
|---|---|
| IFRS | International Financial Reporting Standards / IFRS Accounting Standards |
| IAS | International Accounting Standards |
| P&L | Statement of Profit or Loss / Profit and Loss |
| GL | General Ledger |
| ERP | Enterprise Resource Planning |
| FX | Foreign Exchange |
| FS | Financial Statements |
| TB | Trial Balance |